

A half-gallon tub of peanut butter ice cream, studded with chocolate-covered peanut butter cup pieces, gives this pint-free freezer staple a straightforward setup. The base is peanut butter flavored all the way through, so the mix-ins aren’t carrying all the weight. Compared with vanilla ice cream loaded with peanut butter cups, this one keeps the peanut butter theme going from start to finish. In Publix’s Premium line, it sits among the more mix-in-heavy flavors, with the chocolate shell adding a little snap and the candy filling folding back into the same nutty note.

Tried this? Be the first to share.