

Two slices of Martin's potato bread get buttered, then griddled with American cheese in the middle until the outside browns and the cheese melts through. It's a very simple build, closer to a classic diner version than anything heavily stacked, and it sits in Shake Shack's menu as a meatless option alongside burgers and fries. Martin's bread brings a soft, slightly sweet crumb and a thin, crisped crust once it hits the flat-top. American cheese melts evenly and stays smooth instead of breaking into oil. Some locations will add tomato on request, but the standard version keeps to bread, butter, cheese, and heat.

Tried this? Be the first to share.